the gathering novel carroll emily winsnap land amidst

The gathering novel carroll emily winsnap land amidst series#

The drama seems rather contrived in this one, with Emily seeming to get into fights with everyone for reasons that are not entirely in her control. Add in the romance plotline which has sprung up in the later books, with Emily's boyfriend Aaron, and it's sure to be a hit with kids who have always secretly wanted Emily's life.Īs for me, I have to say that I'm getting rather sick of the Emily Windsnap books by this point. There's always something very appealing about the story of an ordinary girl who can secretly turn into a mermaid and live a whole nother life beneath the waves. The thing is, though, the reason Kessler can get away with writing so many of these books is that they really are enjoyable reads–especially for a certain demographic of readers, largely made up of tweenage girls.

The gathering novel carroll emily winsnap land amidst series#

If you haven't been keeping count, that means Falls of Forgotten Island is the seventh book in a series while always seems to be wrapped up and finished at the end of every new installment. The story yet again seemed finished, which I was okay with, but then a few years later another book came out. It honestly read like a standalone, so I was a little nonplussed when a sequel came out, but I went ahead and read and enjoyed it. I read the original The Tail of Emily Windsnap novel many, many years ago–back when I was actually in its target audience. This review is also available on my blog, Read Till Dawn. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book via Netgalley. This is another great adventure in this series to interest middle grades readers. The way these three friends handle all this shows that they are just kids, but sometimes need to step up to make the right decision. There are tested friendships, danger, young love, fantasy, adventure, and mystery. This book has so much angst wrapped up in a short story. There is a situation that Emily has to help with that upsets both Shona and Aaron. This takes a lot out of them both, but adventure always seems to find Emily, and before she knows it, she ends up on the other side of a powerful waterfall on a forgotten island no one else can get to. Shona can't resist catching up with the boat taking the others to Forgotten Island and when Emily sees her, she ends up in the water and they get caught up in a terrible current. It doesn't take long for Emily to go off on a sidetrip with Aaron leaving Shona left out. Emily promises Shona, there will be absolutely no adventure, just plenty of fun and relaxation.

In this seventh outing with Emily Windsnap, Emily's family, her best friend Shona and her boyfriend Aaron are headed to a tropical island for a relaxing vacation.

It’s about the only thing I really didn’t like about the book. The cover is absolutely stunning and was what drew me in. Thank you for allowing me access to the book and for the opportunity to leave this review. I apologize that this book just wasn’t for me and that I could not like it. This is not my first middle-grade book as I read them all the time with my own middle-grade children, but I wouldn’t recommend this book to them or to my niece. I don’t think anyone that’s in the age range of older middle-grade books would like this story. I think that tweenage girls who are seeking adventure might like this story because of the mermaid aspect but would also find the confrontations tedious.

However, reading other reviews it seems that every book in the series also had a nice wrap-up. Hopefully, this will be the last book in the series as it seemed to wrap up at the end. Even though it wasn’t two boys trying to seek Emily’s attention, it was still a triangle because she had to often choose between her boyfriend and her best friend which made the storyline awkward.

The storyline also possessed one of my least favorite tropes- the love triangle. That was about the most exciting part of the story as the rest seemed like she was going around picking fights and causing teenager drama with everyone she encountered. The MC Emily has the fantastic gift of transforming into a mermaid and having adventures of her own under the sea. After reading it I don’t believe that I have missed anything major by not reading the other six books, but I did not love the story and I had to put it down and try to finish it multiple times. Before I had requested this book, I did not realize that it was the seventh in this series.